In a pile on Lestrade's desk were the following files on Sorting Sherlock

Discussion segment in which consulting fans sort characters and creators of the show into the Hogswarts Houses


New and original Consulting Fans revisit a classic segment and “resort” Sherlock with new character insights from Series Three and Four. Listen here or download. Shownotes: Three Patch Throwback: Sorting Sherlock (0:16:14) Consulting Fans: Shannon, Drinkingcocoa, MK, Finn Producer/Editor: Emma Casefile: the original Sorting Sherlock segment from Episode 1 This segment was first […]

73 – Three Patch Throwback – Sorting Sherlock


Consulting fans sort Eurus (or try) into a Hogwarts house. Listen here or download. Shownotes: Consulting Fans: Shannon, Rachael, Drinkingcocoa, Finnagain Producer: Shannon, Editor: Caroline Genie the feral child Ariana Dumbledore This segment was first released on July 1, 2017 in Episode 66:  Conductors of Light Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music […]

66 – Sorting Eurus




Consulting Fans Shannon, Emma, Finn, and Alexxphoenix42 try to sort actors Louise Brealey and Amanda Abblington into Hogwarts Houses. Listen here or download. Amanda Abbington interview What Loo Brealey loves This segment was originally posted on November 1, 2015 in Episode 42: DON’T PANIC. It may have been remastered for audibility.   Music Credit Unless otherwise […]

42 – Sorting Sherlock: Loo Brealey and Amanda Abbington


Shannon, and many 221B Con attendees in the Three Patch Podcast Con Suite sort actors Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman. Listen here or download. This segment was originally posted on May 1, 2015 in Episode 36: For Fandom!. It may have been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available for purchase through […]

36 – Live from 221B Con: Sorting Cumberbatch and Freeman


Consulting Fans Shannon, Roane, and Caroline try to sort Sherlock’s childhood dog, Redbeard. Listen here or download. Murray the Irish Setter who plays Redbeard This segment was originally posted on April 1, 2015 in Episode 35: The Bitter Brother. It may have been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available […]

35 – Sorting Sherlock: Redbeard



Consulting fans: Shannon, Drinkingcocoa, Methleigh, MK. Listen here or download. List of Potions on the Harry Potter Wiki This segment was originally posted a December 1, 2014 as Episode 31: Holmes for the Holidays. It may have been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available for purchase through […]

31 – Sorting Sherlock: Wiggins


Consulting Fans: Shannon, Fox Estacado, MK, The Queen of Hearts, finnagain. Listen here or download. This segment was first release on November 1, 2014 in Episode 29: The Smart One. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available for purchase through online retailers such as amazon.com and iTunes. David Arnold […]

29 – Sorting Sherlock: Janine


Consulting Fans: Shannon, Rachael, DrinkingCocoa, Methleigh. Listen here or download. Review of Murdoch’s world:  The Last of the Old Media Empires, mentioning a guy who pees during meetings This segment was first release on August 1, 2014 in Episode 26: Fanworks for Fun and Profit . It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit […]

26 – Sorting Sherlock: Magnussen



Consulting Fans: Shannon, Drinkingcocoa, and Emma. Listen here or download. Skulls and Tea at 221b’s Steven Moffat Quotes Tag Skulls and Tea at 221b’s Mark Gatiss Quotes Tag Steven Moffat on writing the best man speech Steven Moffat’s advice to writers Mark Gatiss loves red herrings:  Moriarty and Mycroft handshake Listeners such as welovethebeekeeper and april…im april sorted the writers […]

25 – Sorting Sherlock: Moffat, Gatiss, and Thompson


Consulting Fans: Shannon, Methleigh, MK, and Drinkingcocoa. Listen here or download. This segment was first release on June 1, 2014 in Episode 24: Looking for Baby Names. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available for purchase through online retailers such as amazon.com and iTunes. David Arnold and Michael Price, Sherlock: […]

24 – Sorting Sherlock: Major Sholto


Consulting Fans Shannon, Rachael, MK, DrinkingCocoa, Clevermanka, Causidicus, 221bjen, Hope of All Trades, Bibliomancer1, and Marilynne McKay sort the Holmes Parents. Listen here or download. This segment was first release on May 1, 2014 in Episode 22: Live From 221B Con. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available […]

22 – Sorting Sherlock: The Holmes Parents



Consulting Fans Shannon, Drinkingcocoa, Emma, and Fox sort the character of Mary Morstan. Listen here or download. Hypable’s Sorting of the Sherlock Characters This segment was first release on March 1st, 2014, in Episode 20: The Elephant in the Room.  It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music […]

20 – Sorting Sherlock: Mary Morstan


Consulting Fans: Shannon, B, Emma, Fox Estacado, Drinkingcocoa In which our panel of consulting fans sorts Detective Inspector Lestrade. Recreational Meta: The Magnificent Decency of Lestrade Listeners weigh in on Lestrade’s character. This segment was first release on November 1st, 2013 in Episode 11: Married to My Work.  It has been remastered for […]

11 – Sorting Sherlock: Greg Lestrade


Consulting Fans: Shannon, Fox, Drinkingcocoa In which our panel of consulting fans sort Mycroft, the most terrifying man you’ll ever meet. Recreational Meta: The Most Dangerous Man You’ve Ever Met This segment was first release on October 1st, 2013 in Episode 10: Fear and Stimulus.  It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit […]

10 – Sorting Sherlock: Mycroft Holmes



Consulting Fans: Shannon, Drinkingcocoa, roane, holyfant Character analysis turned on its head. In which we explore the Sherlock characters by discussing what they’re like in bed. This segment was first release on September 1st, 2013 in Episode 9: Come at Once.  It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music […]

9 – Fucking Sherlock



Part 2 of the discussion between consulting fans Shannon, B, Drinkingcocoa, Rachael, Roane, and Katie  as they try to sort John Watson and discuss his Patronus. Listen here or download. Finding Himself by Minisinoo (Hufflepuff-centric AU in which Cedric Diggory lives) Hufflepuff House Group Character Analysis by Minisinoo This segment was first release […]

7.5 – Sorting Sherlock: John Watson, Part 2



Part 1 of the discussion between consulting fans Shannon, B, Drinkingcocoa, Rachael, Roane, and Katie  as they try to sort John Watson. Listen here or download. This segment was first release on July 1st, 2013 in Episode 7: Could Be Dangerous. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is […]

7 – Sorting Sherlock: John Watson, Part 1


Consulting Fans Shannon, Drinkingcocoa, and Holyfant sort Irene Adler. Listen here or download. *Source for Benedict Cumberbatch’s comment in which he ships Sherlock/Irene This segment was first release on June 1st, 2013 in Episode 6: It’s All Fine. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available for purchase […]

6 – Sorting Sherlock: Irene Adler


Consulting Fans Shannon, Drinkingcocoa, and Holyfant sort Mrs. Hudson. Listen here or download. This segment was first release on May 1st, 2013 in Episode 5: I’ll Be Mother (Not the Mother’s Day Episode) at 0:21:17 time stamp. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available for purchase through […]

5 – Sorting Sherlock: Mrs Hudson



Consulting Fans Shannon, Fox Estacado, and Drinkingcocoa sort characters Anderson and Sally Donovan. Shownotes: JKR’s quote about Neville’s sorting on Pottermore. This segment was first release on April 1st, 2013 in Episode 4: Everyone’s an Idiot at 0:19:57 time stamp. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is available for […]

4 – Sorting Sherlock: Anderson and Donovan


Consulting Fans Shannon, Rachael, the Queen of Hearts, and Drinkingcocoa sort Moriarty into a Hogswarts House. Listen here or download. This segment was first release on March 1st, 2013 in Episode 3: March Moriarty Madness at 0:49:04 time stamp. It has been remastered for audibility. Music Credit Unless otherwise indicated, music is […]

3 – Sorting Sherlock: Jim Moriarty


Consulting Fans  Shannon, Fox Estacado, Methleigh, and The Queen of Hearts discuss how to sort Sherlock Holmes into a Hogwarts House. Listen here or download. Links: – Harry Potter Astrology This segment of Sorting Sherlock was first release on January 6th, 2013 in Episode 1, Birthday’s are Boring  at 1:11:52. It […]

1 – Sorting Sherlock: Sherlock